​

The Dutch House by Ann Patchett

A Reflection on Goodness, Family, and the Cost of Altruism

Book Review by Decoding Desis

​

Ann Patchett’s The Dutch House started off beautifully intriguing — or perhaps I’m one of those "Andreas." I’ve always loved large, old homes; they carry secrets, stories, and a kind of lived-in wisdom. New homes, by contrast, all seem to blend into one another.

As the story unfolds, it reads like Daniel’s autobiography — though he insists it’s really Maeve’s story. The house itself serves as a constant metaphor for legacy, resentment, and memory. About three-quarters into the book, though, I found the pacing slowed. What began as layered and emotional shifted into a quieter, more reflective rhythm.

 

The Most Fascinating Character: Elna Conroy

Of all the characters, Elna Conroy (the first Mrs. Conroy) — the mother — is the most compelling. Like many women of her generation (and even today), she seems to have never truly wanted children. Her purpose was not rooted in motherhood but in service.

Elna’s life is guided by a moral compass so strict it isolates her. She leaves her family to help the poor, believing her children will be fine in the care of their father and the staff in the home. Yet in her quest to live a life of meaning, she abandons her own.

When Elna eventually returns, she offers no apologies — she simply resumes her calling. Her need to serve ultimately pulls her away again, fulfilling the very tragedy their father once foreshadowed.

 

Lessons in “Goodness”

Two lines from the book capture its emotional core:

“Our mother was a saint who couldn’t live with us because we weren’t good enough. Or maybe we were too good, too rich, too spoiled — it was hard to keep track.” — Chapter 12
“She did what she wanted to do, and what she wanted to do was to help other people. We just weren’t other people.” — Chapter 14

These quotes summarize the paradox of goodness that The Dutch House explores: When compassion for the world eclipses compassion for one’s own family, can it still be called goodness?

​

The Cost of Altruism

Elna Conroy is compared to Mother Teresa in the novel — a woman revered for her selflessness. Yet I believe Patchett forces readers to ask a difficult question: If someone dedicates their life to helping others, is that entirely selfless?

Sometimes, philanthropy and service can mask personal wounds or unmet needs. In Elna’s case, her devotion to the needy seems to fill the very void she created by abandoning her family. Her goodness is not false, but it comes at a cost — the loss of intimacy, forgiveness, and belonging.

​

Final Reflection

Who would have thought that the world’s greatest philanthropists — in their extreme devotion to helping others — might lose their loved ones in the process?

This book left me wondering: Does true altruism even exist?

​

​​​​​​